← Digital Desk

COMMERCIAL ECONOMICS · September 29, 2026

Some of the most important customer negotiations I’ve been involved in weren’t about winning the business.

A commercial opportunity creates value only when its margin and strategic benefit justify the people, capital, complexity and management attention it requires. They were about deciding whether we should keep it.

DIRECT ANSWER

Will the economics hold after the announcement?

A commercial opportunity creates value only when its margin and strategic benefit justify the people, capital, complexity and management attention it requires. They were about deciding whether we should keep it.

CEOsCommercial leadersInvestors

KEY POINTS

  • They were about deciding whether we should keep it.
  • Instead, we had a very direct conversation about what needed to change.
  • Sometimes the problem isn’t the customer.

FRANK’S ORIGINAL WORDS

Some of the most important customer negotiations I’ve been involved in weren’t about winning the business.

They were about deciding whether we should keep it.

In one case, we had a major retail relationship that brought many of the things you want from a strategic partner.

Scale.

Transaction volume.

Market presence.

And significant long-term potential.

But when the relationship came up for renewal, we had to look beyond the revenue.

Over time, the service requirements had become more complex, the investment required from us had increased, and the economics no longer reflected what it took to support and grow the business.

Walking away would have been easy to justify.

So would accepting weaker economics simply to protect the revenue.

We did neither.

Instead, we had a very direct conversation about what needed to change.

We simplified the service model, renegotiated the economics and restructured the investment so both organizations had skin in the game.

More importantly, we created incentives that gave both sides a reason to invest in growing the business together.

What followed became one of the largest and most enduring commercial relationships I’ve been part of.

The economics mattered.

But what made the relationship endure was transparency, honesty and trust.

  • It reinforced something I’ve believed ever since:

Sometimes the problem isn’t the customer.

It’s the structure of the relationship.

And the best commercial decisions don’t always come from winning or walking away.

Sometimes they come from having the difficult conversation required to make the relationship work for both sides.

THE OPERATING QUESTION

Will the economics hold after the announcement?

Revenue quality, customer economics, incentives and partnerships that work in operation.

PRIMARY RECORD

Authorship and source context preserved · Record reviewed 2026-10-23

View original source ↗

START WITH THE DECISION

Where is this showing up in your business?

Start a conversation