KEY POINTS
- But when we dug into the numbers, the picture was different.
- Not the quality or longevity of the merchant we were acquiring.
- Because eventually, you get what you incentivize.
FRANK’S ORIGINAL WORDS
Merchant count was growing.
On the surface, that looked like a good story.
But when we dug into the numbers, the picture was different.
Some of what we were calling “new merchants”, effectively new customers being added to the network, weren’t actually new.
An existing location could change ownership or move and be counted as a new merchant. So the headline number was increasing without necessarily increasing the size of the network.
Then we looked at how the sales team was being rewarded.
The incentive was largely tied to signing up new merchants.
Not retention.
Not transaction volume.
Not margin dollars.
Not the quality or longevity of the merchant we were acquiring.
We were rewarding an activity rather than the economic outcome we actually wanted.
So we changed it.
We tightened the definition of net-new merchants so the reporting reflected genuine network expansion.
Then we reworked the incentive structure to put more emphasis on merchant quality, retention and economics.
That gave us a much clearer view of customer acquisition cost and, more importantly, whether the growth we were paying for was actually creating value.
It reinforced something I’ve seen in different forms throughout my career:
A metric can be accurate and still tell the wrong story.
Whenever an organization rewards a number, I want to understand exactly how that number is defined, and what behaviour we’re paying people to create.
Because eventually, you get what you incentivize.
Will the economics hold after the announcement?
Revenue quality, customer economics, incentives and partnerships that work in operation.
Authorship and source context preserved · Record reviewed 2026-10-23
View original source ↗